Advertisement

Nineteen Rules for Dealing with Generation Y Employees

By Rob Bishop and Barry Klein
October 2011

     Comments (23)
Photo of a drill sargeant
Though the authors have taken a harder line with their staff, initial response has been positive and job performance has improved. (Image © MTMCOINS/Istockphoto.com)

Legendary football coach John Madden had only three rules for his players: 1) Be on time; 2) Listen and learn; and 3) Play like hell when I tell you to. Luckily for Coach Madden, he never had to deal with Generation Y.

As all of us in the fitness industry know, Generation Y — born between 1985 and 2002 and also known as "Millennials" or the "Net Generation" — is the key to our workforce. The oldest of them are getting into their late 20s now, and many are still in their teens, which means you've already got a bunch of them on staff. Worse yet, you're soon going to have even more of them.

We thought we understood this group and were doing a pretty good job of managing them. Heck, only two years ago, we even did a talk at the Athletic Business Conference about our successes hiring and managing Millenials. Lately, though, it has seemed as if our staff is doing everything wrong, and we've realized that we'll have nothing but problems if we don't tighten things up.


When we started our business in the mid-'90s, we took a page from Coach Madden's book — and, actually, we were even more succinct. We had just two rules: 1) Be on time; and 2) Take care of the members.

With a small club and a small staff, these two rules served us well. Even our youngest staff people — who were the same age then as several of our employees today — understood why those two rules were so important. They might not have always known what to do, but they didn't have to be told why customer service was important. Everything fell under the catch-all, "take care of the members" — from providing great workouts to answering the phones the right way to cleaning. We certainly did a lot of staff training back then, but there were two key differences between those days and 2011. First, we did not have to define the basics of professional behavior. Second, our young staff actively learned by the examples that were set by us, as well as our senior, more experienced employees.

Let's just say that the old rules no longer apply.

Our business is growing, and everyone we hire is a 20-something. We actually have a gifted staff at the moment, but learning how to manage and motivate Millennials is a continuing education for us. Generally speaking, they do not learn by example (and anyway, many of our "senior" people these days are in their 20s, just like our new college graduates, so they aren't great examples to begin with). We've learned that the Net Generation responds very well to explicit instructions that are not open to interpretation. If they know exactly what's expected of them, the best ones will strive to meet or exceed those expectations. Dealing with them brings to mind what Bill Cosby said about why he had to remind his children to turn on the water when they went to take a shower: "You have to tell them to do that, because if you don't, they'll just wander around the tub."

And so, we've had to come up with a lot more rules. Nineteen, to be exact:

    1) Arrive for your shift, client or class 10 minutes early. You must be ready to work, not still getting settled, when you are scheduled to be working.

    2) Dress neatly and in staff attire. Nothing stained or ripped, and no hats at the front desk. Change clothes if you are going from teaching a class to a personal training session. Don't begin a session sweaty and disgusting.

    3) Arrive having eaten. You aren't taking a break as soon as you arrive.

    4) You also are not going to eat in front of members when it is time for you to have a break. Who wants to see you eat?

    5) Be where you are expected to be. Trainers should be on the floor, not at the desk chatting with each other. Desk personnel should be at the desk, not chatting in childcare. If there's nothing to do, clean something.

    6) Do not leave the building without permission. If you do leave, clock out. We're not paying you not to work.

    7) You don't need a break if you work fewer than six hours. In a six- or eight-hour shift, you can take a 30-minute unpaid break outside the building, or you can take a brief paid break inside the building. You'll be paid because you are available to us if need be. (This is consistent with Pennsylvania's employment law.)

    8) Use of Facebook, Twitter and YouTube is prohibited, even from your own mobile device.

    9) Phone calls and text messages can be dealt with during your break. If you are using text messaging for business purposes (communicating with clients), do so out of view of other members.

    10) No mobile usage of any sort in the pool building or in childcare.

    11) No headphones may be worn at work unless for approved purposes (such as building a group-exercise playlist).

    12) No personal business should be conducted while at work. Pay your bills at home.

    13) No recreational reading of books or magazines while at work. If you are on the desk, you may browse the Web (no audio or video sites) so that members see you as alert and your head is upright.

    14) Park your car away from the building. Customers get to park close, not you.

    15) Your timesheet is your responsibility. If it's incorrect, your pay will be incorrect.

    16) Maintain an appropriate professional distance from members. They want to get to know you, but don't discuss your problems. We're supposed to listen to their problems, not the other way around.

    17) Staff members are expected to yield equipment and spots in classes to members. Yes, you will give up your group-cycling bike when a member comes in to a full class, even if that class has started.

    18) Exhibit professional behavior at all times. Someone can hear you, even if you think they can't. No gossip about members, staff or our business.

    19) Drinks must be paid for. Really. The cooler is not your home refrigerator.

That we could come up with 19 rules at all should make it obvious that our employees really had been doing everything wrong, and we weren't being explicit enough in our expectations of them. We presented these new rules at an all-hands meeting, along with a "four strikes" process to deal with offenses. Strike Zero is a first-time violation that is addressed on the spot, followed by Strikes One and Two that result in meetings with management. Strike Three means immediate and serious consequences (loss of shift, dismissal or other appropriate action).

We were pleased with the initial response from our staff. Without any pushback or fuss, we saw immediate improvements in appearance, timely arrivals and overall professional behavior. Few Strike Zero violations occurred over the first few weeks, and we saw hints that our business performance was improving. We're not quite ready to call Coach Madden to tell him that 19 is the new magic number for rules, but at least our staff isn't just wandering around the tub.



Health clubs    Net generation    rules    employees    Millennials    Generation Y   

Rob Bishop and Barry Klein are owners of Elevations Health Club in Scotrun, Pa.
 

Comments:

The younger generation has a sense of entitlement to them. They come in and expect clients to come to them magically rather than work for them. They seem to think they will make $50,000 right off the bat. I had to work my butt off to get to where I am now. We try to hire great employees. Many put on a great show to get the job. In my experience the last couple years hiring, people seem lazy and do not want to work, young and older. Luckily for the most part we have a great staff but there is 1 spot we are trying to fill that has a lot of turnover because of entitlement and laziness. For example, I hired a personal trainer (who was older) who was gung ho when I interviewed him. So excited. I gave him a list of leads to contact and he was going to start right away. Next day I get a call. "Ya, Im not gonna call people so this isnt going to work". WHAT?! They DO NOT magically appear. You must work!

no name  manager  11/15/2012 11:16:37 AM

I have many employees that fit this Generation; however, I will be honest in saying that many of my staff have been mentors to their management with some of the life lessons that they can share 1) Have several staff that believe in the Disney face, disney style customer service. These are people that are use to quality and often having their expectations met or they will tweet, yelp or facebook it to shame. So, I often feel this generation has a pulse on things but need a partnership to have a trusted feeback loop. I have things to share in my early 40s that they appreciate or laugh at; and they know they can share their ideas and not feel like they are square pegs in a round society. 2) Another one of my favorite former employee was a woman who was 24. She could have easily been fast tracked to Director level within a short couple years. She had a dynamic postiive attitude with a sharp can-do mind. She could solve a problem fast as the technogy we often tease our generation for loving. She could use old fashion ideas as well as streamlined, and had no problem getting her hands dirty if the bathroom blew up when our Environmental crew was on break. Our generations are part of the diversity of things. I like a multigenerational membership, workforce as much as I life a culturally diverse one. Respect has no real lines anymore on age as I can tell while I also parent my young children. My own children know they have the right to have: a voice; get to be respected no matter what age or race or gender, and will earn more responsbility and freedom if they use grace, dignity, and a good work ethic. Give our generations more credit. Don't get me wrong, on a very quick level there were some points made, but managing/coaching for me on any real level... has been about building rapport, trust, momentum, passion in spirit, comradry, and allowing room for growth which often happens by making mistakes and taking healthy risks with mentors of all ages and abilities.

TriCoach Jenny  Manager Member Services  12/29/2011 8:56:43 PM

While reading these comments, I feel the irritation through words and how there is definitely a pointing the finger at who is worse off and who is the blame...Gen X, Gen Y, Baby Boomers...etc. I agree that it is management's job to hire quality people. It comes to the point though, that the quality pool is so poor. At times, management has to throw some expectations and standards out the door, to hire mediocre.

LYO  Unspecified  11/28/2011 2:14:56 PM

I find it intriguing that this thread is still going strongly, with many "passionate" postings. While us "old folks" may have not done things perfectly, we understood the meaning of two phrases that seem to be missing from the training/education/vocabulary of the majority of GenYers - "personal responsibility" and "initiative". Painting everyone with one brush as never worked, starting with the dawn of time. But frequently a broad brush stroke is accurate and it is those who are outside of the grouping that need to pull the rest of their generation along and "do better" with their children than we have apparently done with ours by the judgement of the Gen Y respondants.

Rebecca  Aquatics and Risk Management Coordinator  11/28/2011 11:25:15 AM

As a member of Gen Y, I find many of the comments and the overall concept of this article to be incredibly insulting. Management, it is YOUR job to interview and hire quality employees. My generation has its flaws, as does every other generation out there (look at all of you older people who have been the leaders, drivers, and oh so wise financial experts that have been part of bringing our country into its current state) but its rather judgemental and ridiculous to label the entire generation as lazy. If you think all your young employees are lazy idiots, chane your hiring process so that you did the good workers out there. And next time you complain about how terrible Gen Y is, just remember it is you who raised us.

Jean  Swim coach and IT consultant  11/23/2011 5:40:35 PM

Wow! Some interesting comments. From reading most, you can pretty much get a feel of what generation they are from. I am considered a "baby boomer"; and I can tell you from experience in another field (16 years as a professional firefighter/paramedic) the fitness industry IS NOT the only area where this has become an issue. What use to be the norm of putting in your time; paying your dues; and earning the respect of not only your co-workers, but the profession you are in...has now become "what's in it for me" when they walk through the door. And while some of the comments I agree with; not ALL "Mils" are this way, (I currently have one as a part time staff member that I would hire full time over ANY generation: however a large portion are. Trust me; "baby boomers", Generation X or whoever we may be; we DON'T have all the answers; but it's a good chance we've dealt with a certain situation before, and have a pretty good idea of what's going on. Lastly I would respond to some of the comments....REGARDLESS of your generation....it is often difficult to look in the mirror and see your faults! Whatever generation you are! And remember...."respect is a two way street"! Thanks for sharing; a GREAT article!

Keith  Director of Fitness  11/3/2011 12:05:25 PM

I have to agree a little with Brian. Losers is a harsh word to use when describing anyone and is quite judgmental but from working with this population of kids his statements are somewhat true. They have a sense of entitlement not deserved but what the older adults (parents) have done is set this presidence with them. This generation of kids the articles about have learned to manipulate their parents and the parents give in, why? Because they"re so busy either doing their own thing. The rules listed don't mean as much to me as the statement that everything has to be spelled out for these kids. They do tend to be on the lazy side, just doing the bare minimum and thinking it's good. The easiest thing to do with them is right for the get go, if you see signs of what I call "weaseling" let them know right off the bat, I pay you, you will do it my way or else i'm going to have to let you go. That's real! If you sugar coat it because they have some emotional issues with following directions, they'll eat you alive but if you're straight up right from the get go, they know you mean business. And let them know too, you took a chance on them and they owe you...

Different Dave    10/27/2011 12:55:48 PM

Amazing! Now I realize I'm not the only one who deals with this problem... Thank you!

Jeremy  General Manager  10/24/2011 11:28:09 AM

Brian - I would be surprised if you are in charge of anything. And if you are, it is probably failing. Nice job!

Richard  Manager  10/18/2011 3:47:27 PM

Generation Y is without a doubt the greatest collection of losers this country has ever seen. They lack the personal characteristics from prior generations of Americans namely -- hard work, discipline, ethics, morality, educational achievement, etc to but name a few. I guess they are always expecting their Baby Boomer parents to bail them out of every situation in their pathetic lives.

Brian    10/14/2011 6:46:55 PM

The only difference between Gen X and Gen Y is that Gen X feels entitled to mercilessly pass judgement. It's incredibly difficult to deal with complacent Gen Xers in the workplace. The "can do" attitude of Gen Y is consistently met with the "refusal to teach" by Gen X. The palpable friction in the workplace is equally to blame on Gen X. Research shows that Gen X is considerably less interested in direct management owing to a "rebel" mentality honed from reporting to Baby Boomers. The result? A gap in management and leadership for Gen Y. How fortunate that we're willing to step up and create our own paths that result in actually productivity rather than 19-point lists. Gen Y, these workplace rules make sense to you because they were instilled by Baby Boomers. Congratulations on stepping up and posting the "official" list on the community refrigerator. Now maybe you will actually take some responsibility for your reports, rather than seek to avoid blame and harassment over their lack of professionalism...

Callie  Associate Director for International Recreation Research   10/7/2011 10:14:42 AM

Annie, I completely agree with you. I am somewhat dissapointed after reading this article and some of the comments below. This is not a single generational issue anymore. With the increasing popularity of social media and texting with older generations it is actually becoming just as hard to control it with them than the new generations. Younger generations are taught to put phones away and eliminate distractions in class until the class is done. I have an easier time with them than the older generations when it comes to social media and phone use because in in the older generations minds younger people don't have a clue about managing and shouldn't be telling them what to do and the older generations are better at hiding it from their supervisors. If you don't lay out things for employees to do they are going to find things to occupy their boredom no matter what their age is. When I hire someone, I hire for ability, drive and willingness to learn but that doesn't mean I don't get a few bad apples once in a while. But I will tell you one thing, Age is not a factor. It sounds like you need to open your mind to what your facility could be and the potential that these kids could live up to with the proper guidance. Do they need rules? Yes - but so does everyone else. This generation could give you some of the best ideas that your facility has ever had but you need to give them a chance. It is not about what is convenient for you, it is about taking the time to mold them to reach their greatest potential. I was fortunate to have a great boss who recognized my potential despite my mistakes and would guide me instead of condemning me. This truely shaped me into the manager that I am today and I can tell you that without his help I would have turned out completely different. There were times when I needed some tough love as a worker but it always made me a better person no matter how mad it made me at the time. I would encourage you to take a step out of your comfort zone and take the time to encourage instead of condemn. You could be the guiding light in their lives but it is completely up to you. My advice: Employ their strengths and work with their weaknesses. The world is constantly changing and we need to adapt and who knows? You might create the atmosphere that your patrons are looking for.

LTS  Manager  9/30/2011 1:20:48 PM

These rules come from a poor process in employee hiring. I was born in 1988, and you are making a general theory about your employees apply to an entire generation? The article was nicely written at least.

A.   Unspecified   9/27/2011 8:01:43 PM

As a supervisor who is under 35, I can agree with some things in the article and will actually steal some rules for our use (thanks for sharing) but I believe these characteristics apply more to our part-timers in the field as opposed to the young full time staff I supervise. Of course it is my perspective but I recently was asked to write a blog about Millennials for NRPA a while back. Check it out; I think it deals with more of the Young Professional in the field as opposed to the part-time worker. http://www.nrpa.org/make-way-for-the-millennials/

Shane  Rec Superintendent  9/20/2011 9:27:01 AM

Wow, judging from these responses, there must be a lot of Baby Boomers in management. As a Gen X'r, my experience is that my Gen Y staff are NEW to working. Of course they need guidance! Meanwhile, I bet if you turned around some (not all) of these rules, you might find an answer to the question of making your workplace extremely enticing to these 'kids' - who actually probably have a lot to offer and often probably work harder than the minimum wage we give them! Ex: 17 - (As stated, plus...) We will offer staff-only workout times before or after our facility opens/closes, just clean up after yourself or we'll take away the privledge. If it makes me a 'helicopter' manager to see it from the next generation's perspective, then Oh Well. It seems to me we best find some middle ground, since they are the up-and-commers!!!

Annie  Aquatics  9/9/2011 2:48:21 PM

Hey Dave the Program Director: If you re-read rule #15 you see that "Your timesheet is your responsibility". If the employee is responsible for clocking in and clocking out or filling out the time card, but forgets to do so, that really is a problem for the employee not the employer. The employer can and will, of course, make it up on the next check but you can pretty much bet the mortgage that the employee will never forget to clock in or out again.

Cliff  Owner/Instructor  9/9/2011 11:35:33 AM

I wish I worked at your gym! My MANAGER actually asked me, "Why are you so early for your classes?" (I come 10-15min before to set up, say hello to members, etc). The staff is bad, but my managers could also use these rules!

Melanie   Instructor  9/8/2011 5:41:30 PM

WOW really only 19 rules for staff you are pretty lucky. Yes but it is now not just the staff you need to deal with but your customer base is also of that age range. Have to now explain why you have to return the weights to the racks, why you have to pay memberships on time, why we do not allow food and drink in the facility and yes why you need to take a shower before you get in the pool after a work out. We always had rules but some needed no explaination as they do today. We all have some staff that need to be told to turn the water on which is ok but once the water is on do we really need to tell them to trun it off too. Oh yea my favorite comment is I should get paid what you do since we both do the same stuff around here. This is one I hear alot from the College grads we hire and more so if they have a higher degree even if not in the industry. They do not realize that some of us old farts also have degrees. They do not take into account that we have as much time in the business as they do on earth and have spent countless hours in a variety of training courses and now will add one more from HR on how to deal with a MIL. I was taught to call all my spervisors, clients and members by there first name which was Sir and if that did not work then it had to be Ma'am.

Hey You  Yo Boss  9/8/2011 4:28:58 PM

As a coach and a member of a fitness staff, those who do not need the above rules are lucky. I have long witnessed the over-inflated display of entitlement shown by the younger Mil's, as well as the generation coming afterward. I used to coach the way I was coached: no one had to tell me when to show up, what to do, how to act or how to wear my uniform. Because I loved my "job", I just did it. Now I have to explain ludicrously simple ideas to the tune of "I got it...jeeesh" and then find proof of just the opposite. These days I could offer players/young staffers $1M because I won the lottery and decided to share. They would ask why only 1M instead of saying thank you. These days, a pat on the back from yesteryear after being adjusted for inflation turns into "show me the money". The only good thing that has happened from this pitiful economy is that we have replaced a lot of the entitled Mil's with downsized, industrious workers who are thankful to have a job regardless of the size of the check. And to top it off, they actually smile while working!

Tom  Coach/Trainer  9/8/2011 12:02:07 PM

Dave, You must live in an alternate universe where employees turn out to be exactly like they are in an interview and employers have time clock ESP which allows them to know if an employee clocked in and out at the appropriate times. I am guessing you are part of the problem in terms of this age group acting the way they do. If you are not a parent already, I suspect you will eventually be one of the "helicopter parents" who believe their child should never be inconvenienced, frustrated or unhappy. I am glad to hear this organization is doing something to address these issues. How are millennials going to respond if they ever have to face real heartache or disaster when no one has provided them with coping skills? I know, I know. You would hold their hands and give them bon-bons and tell them nothing is their fault…

Erin    9/8/2011 11:31:54 AM

I just recieved a resume' from a personal trainer that said "I'll work your butt off" and has numerous misspelled words. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say don't use the word "butt" in your resume' and use that nifty tool called spell check. I just keep thinking how am I going to deal with these young kids. I need your 19 rules!

Marcy  Fitness Manager  9/8/2011 11:17:44 AM

Two quick comments: 1) If you need rules like these...then you're not doing a very good job with your hiring process. 2) Where I'm from it's the employer's responsibility to ensure that an employee's pay is correct. Glad I don't work for you...but I'd play for John Madden any day!

Dave  Program Director  9/8/2011 11:09:43 AM

Wow! It's like you were at our club last week. We just had to review our break policy with staff because an employee was taking a one hour break working out in the gym while working a six hour shift.

Leslie   Co-Manager  9/8/2011 10:59:45 AM

Post a comment

Name:
Job Title:
Email:
(not published)
Comment:  
(maximum 1,000 characters)  
Search articles:

 

Related Pages

Retro Fitness CEO Eric Casaburi Talks ...
Retro Fitness, a franchise offering a state-of-the-art workout experience in a checkerboard-and-hair-band atmosphere, has thrived ...

Athletic Departments Apply Disney Principles ...
A young boy attending an Arizona State University football game last fall slipped and skinned his knee. Nothing unusual about that, ...

Colleges Seek Third-Party Help in AD Searches
It has been dubbed the "Wonder Blunder." A botched concert promotion, in which the budget-weary University of Hawaii paid a ...

Related Categories
in the Buyers Guide:

 

Featured Vendor

 

Facility of the Week

Ithaca College Athletics and Events Center

See project slideshow

 



Facebook   Twitter   LinkedIn   YouTube   YouTube   AB Forum   ABC & Expo

Advertisement



Advertisement



Advertisement