Advertisement
AB Newswire

Home Account Search
Controversial Rule Bans 11-Year-Old From Scoring TDs
Demias Jimerson, an 11-year-old running back for Wilson Intermediate School in Malvern, Ark., "scores almost every time he touches the ball," according to Terri Bryant, the school's principal. In fact, in one game, the sixth-grader scored seven touchdowns for his undefeated team.

That's why the Wilson Intermediate Football League has invoked the Madre Hill Rule — named after the former Arkansas Razorbacks and Oakland Raiders running back. Once Hill, who also attended Wilson Intermediate School, scored three touchdowns, and if his team had at least a 14-point lead, officials banned him from scoring any more touchdowns.

"If you were looking at them, you would say they were very ... similar," Darryl Baker, who coached Hill and now referees Jimerson's games, told Fox16 in Little Rock. "They both run really fast [and] run with the same style."

Bryant, who also is commissioner of the Wilson Intermediate Football League, told reporter Josh Rosenthal that the rule isn't meant to punish Jimerson. Rather, it's there to help the other fifth- and sixth-graders on the field develop as football players, too.

But Tina Korbe, in a post on the news and commentary website HotAir.com, claims Bryant made the wrong move. "Doesn’t the principal see? Running with Jimerson does develop the other players," Korbe wrote. "Maybe they’re not immediately able to discern the ways they’ve improved. But, for every time a kid comes only oh-so-close to tackling Jimerson, he’s going to tackle some other less-speedy quarterback with greater ease. In other words, Bryant and the parents of the other children are missing a prime opportunity to encourage their kids to keep pushing and to teach them all that they can do is their best but that, eventually, their best will pay off — if not on the football field, then in the increased disciplined and irrepressible optimism they cultivated while competing with Jimerson."

As for Jimerson, he doesn't seem to mind having to follow the Madre Hill Rule. "I … got shocked, because I didn't know that was gonna happen, but it did," he said. "I'm okay with it."
Posted At 9:34 AM • Comments (11)

Ridiculous. Why punish him for his ability to score at will on the opposition? Like Korbe said, if you want the other players to develop and improve their skills, let them try to stop the best player on the field. They'll have to keep working harder and harder to do so and will have a stronger sense of accomplishment once they finally do bring him down short of the endzone.
Comment By Brian Evans At 10/3/2011 11:46 AM
OMG! If Emma's scoring total keeps increasing this could be possible. 'The Emma Miller Rule' LOL!
Comment By Bill Miller At 10/3/2011 11:53 AM
Jimerson said 'I'm ok with it.' It sounds like this boy is more mature than most adults, stepping aside and giving his teammates offensive opportunities they may not have had if he was allowed to continue to carry the ball. At 11 years old, learning to be a team player is more important than scoring numerous touchdowns. Some day he'll make a fabulous leader, because he's been taught that individual play is not as important as developing the entire team. BRAVO to his coaches and parents for influncing such a great attitude! After all, they are only 11.
Comment By Bonnie Nicolai At 10/3/2011 12:22 PM
The headline is misleading. Really the fact he will be allowed to score 3 touchdowns AND score again if his team doesn't have a 14 point lead is perfect for youth sports development. A classy coach would do that anyway w/o the league impossing the rule. Why a middle school coach wants to run the score up with one kid is beyond me. Talk about developing talent, I am sure that there are other kids on the Wilson team that would love the chance to run the ball when the team has a comfortable lead.
Comment By Kent At 10/3/2011 12:22 PM
The league shouldn't have to implement this rule at this level. The coaches should be having this young player either sit out and allow other players a chance to play and develop or giving him the chance to learn and play some other positions. Over specialization at this age is not a good thing. Learning to play multiple positions will allow him to become a much more well rounded football player which will make some HS and college coaches happy in the future. At this level, it needs to be about learning and development, not winning. We've got plenty of emphasis on winning at higher levels.
Comment By JH At 10/3/2011 12:30 PM
Congrats to Demias on his skill level and dominance. To be compared to Madre Hill is a huge compliment. One correction though Demias is actually from Malvern, AR not Mulvern.
Comment By Josh At 10/3/2011 12:39 PM
JH is correct.
Comment By tim hammond At 10/4/2011 7:42 AM
This is a sign of poor coaching. The kid plays quarterback. Teach him to throw the ball and hand off to other player. A good coach could develop him and still keep the game close.
Comment By ATB At 10/4/2011 11:28 AM
This is way too much regulation. The league should have a policy stating that if a team is more then 3-4 touchdowns ahead that the player can't score anymore TDs. Maybe we should also regulate spelling bees for those students getting perfect scores, because it offends those who don't get perfect scores. Have a little common sense and forget all the ridiculous regulations
Comment By Jeff Friesen At 10/5/2011 11:16 AM
Pussication of America. Rub some dirt on it and walk it off.
Comment By Yourmom At 10/7/2011 7:41 AM
Here's the problem, too many comments on an obvious situation. He's good, so get better and stop him from scoring.
Comment By Jim At 10/7/2011 2:48 PM
Comments :
 
Name :
Email :
       
 
Comments :





Facebook   Twitter   LinkedIn   YouTube   YouTube   AB Forum   ABC & Expo

Advertisement



Advertisement



Advertisement