
I thought I’d heard just about every community recreation facility design request possible. But then, while working with a municipal client on a new building, my team and I were asked a question all of us should have — in retrospect — been expecting: How can we protect our staff in an active shooter situation?
The question, asked late in the design process, was based on a recent incident at another public building in the region. I remember the general vibe in the room was disappointment that we needed to have a discussion like that. But it was a justifiable concern, and we ended up including a bullet-resistant door and frame in our design specifications for the first time. Located at the entrance to an administrative suite near the front desk area, the door and frame look like any other door and frame, but they can prevent penetration by small-caliber bullets (which is considered a “Level 1” bullet-resistant material on a 10-level scale).
For extra peace of mind, the same client requested a second door leading from the administrative suite to outside the building for a quick escape if something awful were to happen. The additional door, which was not a required exit, contains no exterior hardware and is intended only for escape in an emergency.
Such a heightened level of security design is not something we used to discuss at length with clients. Municipal rec centers more often serve as reunification points in the aftermath of a shooting or other tragedy — rather than the site of the tragedy itself. Now, however, the topic of increased security, and the hardening of specific spaces within a municipal recreation center, is a normal part of our design conversations. (My firm, Brinkley Sargent Wiginton Architects, also has a law enforcement design group, which gives us additional insight when designing for security.)
Additionally, we often rely on the standards, guidelines and policies outlined by The International Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) Association — which adhere to a multi-disciplinary approach to crime prevention via urban and architectural design and management of built and natural environments.
While bullet-resistant panels on the front of control desks are becoming more common at community rec centers, another one of BSW’s recent municipal rec projects involved the installation of attack-resistant film on the front doors and surrounding entrance-area glass. The film is designed not to withstand a bullet but to slow it down, and it hinders the efforts of someone trying to access the building with a hammer, axe or other weapon. The conventional thinking is that a would-be intruder would give up before wasting additional precious time — or take long enough trying to break in to give the cops time to show up. While this type of preventive measure does add another layer of security, the client and the design team need to make sure that the protective material would not void the glass warranty.
Another common front-desk add-on request is a panic button. In those cases, the fundamental question always revolves around what the button should do. Sound an alarm? Set off a silent alarm? Trigger cameras or microphones? Call 911? Many times, a panic button can be programmed to do several of those things at the same time. These are operational questions that must be answered before a button is installed, and panic buttons should be tested regularly to make sure the technology is operating correctly.
It’s important to assess (or reassess) security design outside recreation centers, too. CPTED focuses heavily on parking lot sightlines and recommends enhancing visibility by minimizing landscaping that blocks views across parking spaces and into facilities, as well as eliminating screens or privacy walls in front of service areas and other places that could attract nefarious activity. Some of these suggestions can be at odds with other design-related objectives, so they might need to be discussed among all parties involved to obtain a general consensus.
Additionally, if you’re considering increased hardening of your community recreation center or another facility, it is vital to engage public safety professionals as early in the planning process as possible. Local police and fire officials, for example, can help ensure that additional security measures comply with local, state and federal code requirements, and they also can function as advisors about specific security options.
We’re entering a new era of security-related facility design, and it’s crucial to be aware of the increasing options available while not sacrificing other core design strategies.
































