As frequently noted in the pages of Athletic Business and its AB Today digital newsletter, high temperatures during preseason summer practices are a known danger for which coaches need to plan. Recently, Arizona State University faced intense scrutiny after transfer hockey player Matthew Mayich collapsed and was hospitalized following a mid-August workout in conditions to which he was not acclimated. If coaches, or any individuals allowed to conduct outdoor workouts, fail to consider heat risks, athletes could suffer heatstroke, a silent and all-too-often deadly illness that occurs when the body has been exposed to high temperatures and particularly when performing intense physical activity in high temperatures.
According to the University of North Carolina’s National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research, 12 athletes have died from heatstroke since 2020. During the past 25 years, heat-related fatalities among athletes totaled 64. When coaches do not take the heat into consideration, athletes risk suffering heatstroke. A good example of how the courts analyze heatstroke cases, and the legal jeopardy that can result from underappreciating heat risk, is Stroud-Collins vs. Richland School District One, 2024-CP-40-03456.
Environmental impact
Jordan Stroud, a rising freshman, was preparing to play football at Lower Richland High School in South Carolina. Prior to the season, Stroud attended a practice held on a June day when the temperature topped 104 degrees Fahrenheit.
According to the South Carolina High School League, before athletes are allowed to participate in any athletics events, they must have a preparticipation physical exam. The SCHSL also requires schools to monitor Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) readings every day before practice. The WBGT is a measure of heat stress in direct sunlight, taking into account temperature, humidity, wind speed, sun angle and cloud cover in relation to solar radiation. The purpose of the test is to provide coaches with a guideline for when athletics events should be canceled, postponed or modified to mitigate the extreme risk of heatstroke. For example, if the WBGT is greater than 90, exercising in direct sunlight will stress the body after only 15 minutes. As a result, it is recommended that a 45-minute break is taken every hour.
Even though he initially attended the practice only to observe, and claimed that he had yet to have his preparticipation physical exam, Stroud took part in the practice. In addition, despite the temperature exceeding 104 degrees Fahrenheit, Stroud claimed that the school failed to check the WBGT before practice and/or did not follow established guidelines based on WBGT data. If it had, the school should have either delayed or canceled the practice.
During practice, Stroud collapsed and suffered hyperthermia associated with heat and hypotension, which led to traumatic rhabdomyolysis, acute kidney injury, renal failure, anxiety, anemia, liver failure and respiratory failure. Stroud was taken to the hospital, where he was placed in a medically induced coma for 10 days. During nearly two months of hospitalization, he required four surgeries and dialysis. One surgery involved removing muscle from Stroud’s leg, and he now requires a brace when walking.
As a result of his injuries, Stroud's mother, Ashley Stroud-Collins, sued Lower Richland High School, Richland School District One, the South Carolina Department of Education and the SCHSL. The lawsuit alleged that coaches and school officials failed to follow established heat-safety protocols before Stroud suffered a severe heatstroke. In particular, the lawsuit claims that the coaches and school officials were negligent or grossly negligent for failing to properly monitor the day’s WBGT readings; conducting practice despite the WBGT levels reportedly exceeding 92.1 degrees, the threshold at which practices are supposed to be canceled; failing to implement an appropriate heat-acclimatization plan; and not having a cold-water immersion tub available to immediately treat heatstroke.
Finally, Stroud-Collins argued that her son displayed signs of heat illness before collapsing during practice and that coaches and school officials had a duty to operate the football program in a reasonably safe manner and to protect the health and safety of their student-athletes. By failing to conduct a WBGT test and follow the safety procedures prescribed by the SCHSL, Stroud-Collins argued the coaches and school officials breached their duty to Stroud.
On defense
The school district moved to dismiss the case, denying that it was negligent, that school officials ignored dangerous weather conditions or that they failed to implement appropriate heat-safety measures.
In particular, the school district claimed that Stroud received a preparticipation physical examination the day before the practice and that he participated in the conditioning practice voluntarily, not because the coaching staff required him to participate. In addition, the school district claimed that the coaching staff tried to cool Stroud down by packing him with ice and tried to move him to the cold immersion tubs but were unable to move him.
Finally, the school district argued that it did monitor the WBGT. According to the notes of the athletic trainer at the practice, she was watching the WBGT, and it never broke 82.5. If the WBGT is between 80 and 85, exercising in direct sunlight will stress your body after 45 minutes, requiring athletes to take a 15-minute break each hour. The athletic trainer’s notes further documented that protocols were followed regarding breaks, and no athletes exhibited any signs of heat-related illness. Therefore, the school district claimed the evidence demonstrated that the coaches and school officials acted properly and satisfied their duty of care to Stroud.
The district court, however, denied the coaches' and school district’s motion to dismiss, and the case proceeded to a jury trial.
After a weeklong trial and nearly six hours of deliberations, the jury rejected the school district’s claims and found the coaches and school district grossly negligent in regard to Stroud’s injuries. As a result, the jury awarded $4.8 million in damages — $4 million to Stroud for his damages, as well as $800,000 to his mother.
Tort liability or worse
While a $4.8 million award should make it clear to coaches and athletics administrators that following heat-related guidelines during athletics events is important for the health and safety of athletes, there are other lessons coaches and athletics administrators can take away from Stroud-Collins v. Richland Cnty. Dist. One.
First, the case demonstrates the importance not only of having an established emergency action plan, but of ensuring that athletics staff and trainers know how to implement it. A plan is only as effective as the people trained to execute it. When holding practices in conditions conducive to heart-related illness, it is essential that coaches and athletic trainers have clearly established heat-safety procedures, including monitoring environmental conditions, gradually acclimating athletes to summer temperatures and having emergency cooling equipment readily available during outdoor workouts. Once these procedures are established, coaches and athletic trainers play a vital role in recognizing dangerous situations, identifying warning signs and responding appropriately once those signs appear. As UNC’s National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research report suggests, even amid persistent media attention to heat risk, coaches are still overworking athletes in dangerous conditions, and athletes are still suffering — and dying — from heat-related events. Therefore, schools must not only establish guidelines on when practices can be held, and when athletes should get rest breaks for water and shade, but follow those guidelines.
Second, while coaches should already know the dangers associated with running practices in extreme temperatures, it seems that some coaches still maintain the old-school belief that pushing athletes to their limits in the heat is good for their conditioning or will help the team win games. This case should send a clear message that coaches have a legal duty to protect their athletes and not expose the athletes to greater risks than those inherent in the activity. If they do, the coaches and schools may be held negligent for any injuries resulting from their actions.
Finally, if coaches are going to push their athletes to unhealthy extremes and recklessly endanger the athletes under their care by exposing them to dangerous conditions, tort liability is the least of their concerns. In some states, coaches can face criminal liability for heat-related deaths.

































