A third-party investigation initiated by Milford (Ohio) Exempted Village Schools has determined that Milford High School's athletic director failed to report two coaches accused of sexual conduct with students.
The report, obtained by The Cincinnati Enquirer, states that one coach, who has since resigned, allegedly had inappropriate photos of a former coach engaging in sexual conduct with female athletes.
As reported by The Enquirer, the investigation's conclusion states that Aaron Zupka, athletic director at Milford High School since 2019, exhibited "serious judgment lapses, neglect of mandated reporting obligations, and failure to enforce boundaries involving staff and students."
Zupka acknowledged in interviews with investigators that he had heard a rumor about the claims of misconduct in the spring of 2024, Enquirer reporters Grace Tucker, Gillian Stawiszynski and Matthew Cupelli noted Thursday.
Zupka questioned one of the coaches, who denied any wrongdoing, but the athletic director never shared his concerns with the district's human resources department, law enforcement or children's services, stated the July 7 report conducted by Ennis Britton Consulting Group. Ennis Britton Co. L.P.A. provides legal services to school districts and public agencies across Ohio, according to The Enquirer.
Ennis-Britton interviewed Zupka, one parent, district administrators and a volunteer coach regarding the claims of sexual misconduct.
Those interviewed brought up the following allegations against the then-current coach:
- Possessing "photographic evidence" of a former coach engaging in sexual activities with female athletes.
- Engaging in “overly personal interactions that blurred the line between coach and peer.”
- Wiping athletes’ cheeks during emotional moments.
- Transporting female athletes alone to and from meets and practices.
- Holding one-on-one “private practices.”
Police investigated allegations of grooming and child endangerment, according to a report provided under a public records request. The police chief for the Miami Township Police Department, Robert Hirsch, declined to explain why the agency didn't charge the coaches, The Enquirer reported, adding that the case was turned over to the Clermont County Prosecutor's Office, which declined to explain its decision not to press charges.
Zupka has been on administrative leave since Nov. 6, and the district told The Enquirer on Thursday that it "cannot provide a timeline" regarding when a final decision on Zupka's employment will be made.
